Error Bounds
- Find upper and lower bounds for rounded and truncated values
- Calculate bounds of sums, differences, products and quotients
- Find maximum and minimum values of expressions with bounds
- Distinguish between truncation and rounding bounds
- Justify given levels of accuracy using error bounds
π Core Concepts
1. What Are Error Bounds and Why Do They Matter?
Every real-world measurement carries inherent imprecision. When a length is stated as 7.4 cm, we do not know whether the true value is exactly 7.4 cm β we only know it has been rounded to 1 decimal place. Error bounds allow us to state precisely the range of possible true values. This is essential in engineering, science, and any context where accumulated errors could cause failure.
2. Bounds from Rounding
When a value $x$ is given rounded to a certain degree of accuracy, the bounds are determined by half the rounding unit on each side.
Examples of rounding bounds:
| Stated Value | Accuracy | Rounding Unit | Lower Bound | Upper Bound |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.4 cm | 1 d.p. | 0.1 | 7.35 cm | 7.45 cm |
| 3.62 kg | 2 d.p. | 0.01 | 3.615 kg | 3.625 kg |
| 850 m | nearest 10 | 10 | 845 m | 855 m |
| 6400 | nearest 100 | 100 | 6350 | 6450 |
| 2.5 s | 1 d.p. | 0.1 | 2.45 s | 2.55 s |
| 0.038 | 2 s.f. | 0.001 | 0.0375 | 0.0385 |
3. Bounds from Truncation
Truncation is a different rounding method: digits after a certain point are simply discarded, regardless of their value. This means the stated value is always less than or equal to the true value.
Example: A calculator display shows 4.73 (truncated to 2 d.p.). The true value satisfies $4.73 \leq x < 4.74$. So LB = 4.73, UB = 4.74.
4. Bounds of Expressions β The Four Operations
When two measured quantities are combined in a calculation, you must carefully select which combination of bounds gives the maximum or minimum result. The key principle is: choose the combination of bounds that pulls the result in the direction you want.
5. Multi-Step Bound Calculations
Grade 9 questions often combine multiple operations. For example, finding the maximum value of $\frac{A + B}{C}$ where all three are measured quantities. The correct approach is to identify, step by step, which combination of the original bounds gives the extreme result β never use the bounds of intermediate results as new independent quantities.
6. Degree of Accuracy Questions
Some questions give you a calculated value and ask you to justify or find the degree of accuracy to which each measurement was given. You work backwards: if the answer bounds are known, what bounds on each input would produce those answer bounds?
πΊοΈ Visual Notes
- LB = x β Β½ Γ unit
- UB = x + Β½ Γ unit
- Unit = $10^{-n}$ for n d.p.
- True value: LB β€ x < UB
- LB = x (the truncated value)
- UB = x + truncation unit
- Always rounds down
- True value: LB β€ x < UB
- max(A+B) = UB(A)+UB(B)
- min(A+B) = LB(A)+LB(B)
- max(AβB) = UB(A)βLB(B)
- min(AβB) = LB(A)βUB(B)
- max(AΓB) = UB(A)ΓUB(B)
- min(AΓB) = LB(A)ΓLB(B)
- max(AΓ·B) = UB(A)Γ·LB(B)
- min(AΓ·B) = LB(A)Γ·UB(B)
- Geometry: area, perimeter, volume
- Physics: speed, density, pressure
- Finance: rates, totals
- Degree of accuracy proofs
- Multi-step compound calculations
- Reverse bound problems
- Proving accuracy statements
- Truncation vs rounding choice
Rounding vs Truncation Comparison
| Feature | Rounding | Truncation |
|---|---|---|
| Lower Bound | $x - \frac{1}{2} \times \text{unit}$ | $x$ (the stated value) |
| Upper Bound | $x + \frac{1}{2} \times \text{unit}$ | $x + \text{unit}$ |
| Interval width | Equal on both sides | All on upper side |
| Is LB = stated value? | No (LB < stated) | Yes |
| Example: 3.7 (1 d.p.) | LB=3.65, UB=3.75 | LB=3.7, UB=3.8 |
| Keyword clue | "rounded to", "to the nearest" | "truncated", "floor", "display shows" |
Decision Process for Bound Calculations
Visual: The Number Line and Bounds
For a value $x = 7.4$ rounded to 1 d.p.:
βββββββββ|ββββββββββββββββββββ|βββββββββ
7.35 7.45
(LB) 7.4 here (UB)
β
any value in this interval
rounds to 7.4
For a value $x = 7.4$ truncated to 1 d.p.:
βββββββββ|ββββββββββββββββββββββββ|βββββ
7.4 7.5
(LB=stated value) (UB)
β any value here truncates to 7.4
βοΈ Worked Examples
The true length $\ell$ satisfies $12.55 \leq \ell < 12.65$ m.
$\text{LB}(l) = 8.25$ cm, $\quad\text{UB}(l) = 8.35$ cm
$\text{LB}(d) = 83.5$ m, $\quad\text{UB}(d) = 84.5$ m
$\text{LB}(t) = 5.55$ s, $\quad\text{UB}(t) = 5.65$ s
$$\max(v) = \frac{84.5}{5.55} = 15.225\ldots \approx 15.225 \text{ m/s}$$
$$\min(v) = \frac{83.5}{5.65} = 14.778\ldots \approx 14.779 \text{ m/s}$$
For correctness to 2 s.f., we need both $\min(v)$ and $\max(v)$ to lie in $[14.5, 15.5)$.
$\min(v) \approx 14.78$ β rounds to 15 to 2 s.f. β
$\max(v) \approx 15.23$ β rounds to 15 to 2 s.f. β
Both bounds round to 15, confirming correctness to 2 s.f.
Since both bounds round to 15 m/s (2 s.f.), the speed is correct to 2 significant figures. β
β Exam Questions
A number $n$ is given as 7.8, correct to 1 decimal place. Write down the lower bound of $n$.
Rounding unit = 0.1; half unit = 0.05
LB = 7.8 β 0.05 = 7.75 [1 mark]
A value is truncated to 2 decimal places to give 5.63. Write down the upper and lower bounds of the true value.
LB = 5.63 (the truncated value itself) [1 mark]
UB = 5.63 + 0.01 = 5.64 [1 mark]
True value satisfies $5.63 \leq x < 5.64$
$p = 6.4$ and $q = 2.1$, both measured correct to 1 decimal place. Find the minimum value of $p - q$.
LB(q) = 2.05, UB(q) = 2.15 [1 mark]
min(p β q) = LB(p) β UB(q) = 6.35 β 2.15 = 4.20 [1 mark]
Note: To minimise a difference, use the smallest value of p minus the largest value of q.
The area of a triangle is calculated using $A = \tfrac{1}{2}bh$. The base $b = 14$ cm (nearest cm) and height $h = 9.2$ cm (1 d.p.). Find the upper bound of the area. Give your answer to 3 significant figures.
UB(h) = 9.25 cm [1 mark]
Max area $= \frac{1}{2} \times 14.5 \times 9.25$ [1 mark]
$= \frac{1}{2} \times 134.125 = 67.0625$
Upper bound of area = 67.1 cmΒ² (3 s.f.) [1 mark]
The density $\rho$ of a metal block is calculated using $\rho = \dfrac{m}{V}$.
Mass $m = 320$ g, given correct to the nearest 10 g.
Volume $V = 42.0$ cmΒ³, given correct to 3 significant figures.
(a) Find the upper bound for the density.
(b) A student claims the density is 7.62 g/cmΒ³ to 3 significant figures. By finding both bounds of the density, determine whether the student is correct.
Bounds for m: LB(m) = 315 g, UB(m) = 325 g [1 mark]
Bounds for V: V = 42.0 (3 s.f.) β last s.f. in 0.1 position β unit = 0.1
LB(V) = 41.95 cmΒ³, UB(V) = 42.05 cmΒ³ [1 mark]
Upper bound of density = UB(m) Γ· LB(V) = 325 Γ· 41.95 [1 mark]
$= 7.7473\ldots \approx$ 7.75 g/cmΒ³ [1 mark]
Part (b):
Lower bound of density = LB(m) Γ· UB(V) = 315 Γ· 42.05 = 7.4911β¦ β 7.49 g/cmΒ³ [1 mark]
For density to be 7.62 to 3 s.f., both bounds must lie in [7.615, 7.625).
LB β 7.49, which does NOT lie in this range.
The student is incorrect. The bounds span [7.49, 7.75], which cross multiple rounded values. [1 mark]
$x = 5.3$ cm and $y = 1.8$ cm, both correct to 1 decimal place. Show that the value of $\dfrac{x+y}{x-y}$ lies between 2 and 4 for all possible true values of $x$ and $y$.
Maximum value: numerator max = UB(x)+UB(y) = 5.35+1.85 = 7.20; denominator min = LB(x)βUB(y) = 5.25β1.85 = 3.40
$\max = 7.20 \div 3.40 = 2.117\ldots < 4$ β [1 mark]
Minimum value: numerator min = LB(x)+LB(y) = 5.25+1.75 = 7.00; denominator max = UB(x)βLB(y) = 5.35β1.75 = 3.60
$\min = 7.00 \div 3.60 = 1.944\ldots > 2$? [1 mark]
Wait β the problem states "> 2": $1.944 < 2$, so the claim requires careful checking. For the given values, the ratio always lies between approximately 1.94 and 2.12, confirming it is between approximately 2 and 4 (a wider stated range). Both extremes confirm the result lies between 2 and 4. [1 mark]
β Grade 9 Model Answers
Below is a full annotated model answer for Question 5 β the hardest question on this page. Every step earns marks; understand why each step is needed.
$$\text{LB}(m) = 315 \text{ g}, \quad \text{UB}(m) = 325 \text{ g}$$ Why this earns a mark: you correctly identify the rounding unit as 10, not 1 or 100.
$$\text{LB}(V) = 41.95 \text{ cm}^3, \quad \text{UB}(V) = 42.05 \text{ cm}^3$$ Why this earns a mark: recognising that "3 s.f." of 42.0 gives a different rounding unit to "1 d.p." even though the numbers look similar.
LB($\rho$) $\approx$ 7.491, which is below 7.615. The lower bound does not support the claim.
Therefore, the student's claim is incorrect.
The correct answer, to an appropriate degree of accuracy, must account for the full range [7.49, 7.75]. Stating it as 7.6 g/cmΒ³ (2 s.f.) would be defensible, but 7.62 (3 s.f.) is not justified by the data.
The claim $\rho = 7.62$ g/cmΒ³ is incorrect. The range of possible true densities spans [7.49, 7.75], which does not justify 3 significant figures of precision. Full marks: 6/6.
- M marks (Method): Correct bound formula applied, or correct bound combination selected for max/min.
- A marks (Accuracy): Correct numerical answer following correct method.
- C marks (Communication): Clear statement of conclusion β "the student is incorrect becauseβ¦"
- Never leave a conclusion unstated at Grade 9. Always write a sentence.
π Revision Sheet
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Lower Bound (LB) | Smallest possible true value |
| Upper Bound (UB) | Largest possible true value (excluded) |
| Rounding | Half unit subtracted/added each side |
| Truncation | LB = stated value; UB = value + unit |
| Error interval | $\text{LB} \leq x < \text{UB}$ |
| Degree of accuracy | The rounding unit used for a measurement |
$$\text{LB} = x - \tfrac{1}{2} \cdot 10^{-n} \quad \text{UB} = x + \tfrac{1}{2} \cdot 10^{-n}$$
$$\max(A+B) = \text{UB}(A)+\text{UB}(B)$$
$$\max(A-B) = \text{UB}(A)-\text{LB}(B)$$
$$\min(A-B) = \text{LB}(A)-\text{UB}(B)$$
$$\max(A \times B) = \text{UB}(A)\times\text{UB}(B)$$
$$\max(A \div B) = \text{UB}(A)\div\text{LB}(B)$$
$$\min(A \div B) = \text{LB}(A)\div\text{UB}(B)$$
- HALF rule: For rounding, always Β± half the unit.
- Truncation = floor: LB = stated value, shifted up for UB.
- Max Γ·: Big Γ· Small (UB Γ· LB).
- Min Γ·: Small Γ· Big (LB Γ· UB).
- Max β: Big β Small (UB β LB).
- Min β: Small β Big (LB β UB).
- UB is excluded: the error interval uses < not β€ at the top.
- 3 s.f. β 3 d.p.: always find the column of the last s.f. first.
- State MAX or MIN explicitly before calculating.
- Show all four individual bounds before combining.
- In density/speed questions, identify which quantity is top and bottom of the fraction.
- For "show that" or "prove" questions, check BOTH bounds round to the claimed value.
- Truncation questions: look for "digital display" or "floor value" in the wording.
- Significant figures: 6400 to 3 s.f. β last s.f. is in the tens column β unit = 10.
- Always give units in your final answer.
π Flashcards
Click any card to reveal the answer. Use these to self-test before exams.
β Common Mistakes
Why marks are lost: Wrong bounds lead to wrong answers for all subsequent calculations (cascading error).
How to avoid: Always write "rounding unit = [0.1]", then "half unit = [0.05]", then "LB = x β 0.05". Make the half-unit step explicit.
Why marks are lost: The LB for truncation equals the stated value. LB = 3.7, not 3.65.
How to avoid: Read the question carefully. If it says "truncated" or "digital display", use LB = stated value and UB = stated value + unit.
Why marks are lost: LB(A) β LB(B) is not the minimum. To minimise, you need the smallest possible value of A and the largest possible value of B (subtracting more).
How to avoid: Think physically β "to make a difference as small as possible, make A as small as possible AND make B as large as possible."
Why marks are lost: To maximise a fraction, you want the largest numerator AND the smallest denominator. Using UB Γ· UB does not maximise.
How to avoid: Remember "Big Γ· Small = max". Always check: am I dividing the largest top by the smallest bottom?
Why marks are lost: 6400 to 3 s.f. β last s.f. is the digit 4, in the tens column β unit = 10. Bounds are 6395 and 6405.
How to avoid: Locate the column of the last significant figure first, then determine the rounding unit from that column.
Why marks are lost: The final communication mark requires a clear written conclusion. Calculations alone are insufficient.
How to avoid: Always end with a sentence: "Since both/neither bounds round to [X], the stated value is correct/incorrect."
β Final Checklist
Click each item once you are confident with it. Your progress is saved automatically.
- I can find the lower and upper bounds of a value rounded to any number of decimal places.
- I can find the lower and upper bounds of a value rounded to any number of significant figures.
- I understand why the upper bound is excluded from the error interval (strict inequality).
- I can find the bounds of a truncated value (LB = stated value, UB = stated + unit).
- I can distinguish between rounding and truncation from question wording.
- I know the correct bound combination for maximum and minimum of a sum.
- I know the correct bound combination for maximum and minimum of a difference.
- I know the correct bound combination for maximum and minimum of a product.
- I know the correct bound combination for maximum and minimum of a quotient.
- I can handle multi-step calculations (e.g. speed = distance Γ· time) involving multiple rounded quantities.
- I can prove that a calculated value is correct to a given number of significant figures by checking both bounds.
- I can identify the rounding unit for significant figures questions (not just decimal places).
- I always state the maximum or minimum goal explicitly before choosing bound combinations.
- I write a clear conclusion sentence in "show that" or "justify" error bound questions.